Drummer_kidder
And I'm sorry that you hate Brotherhood so much. My main problem with the 2003 version, although it has a lot, a whole lot, a great heaping pile of lot of good... is that in that version, alchemy is inherently evil. Always.
Don't believe me? Go back to the episode where (SPOILING AHOY, in case you haven't got to this) Hohenheim and Ed are in "our world", and Hohenheim explains that "our world" has lots and lots of death, and it is all of these deaths that provide the energy used in Amestris and the world it is in for their alchemy. So any alchemy in that world is fueled by death.
I'll take the zombies, a super-hot Ed, and even Al pairing up with... well, that part isn't really writ in stone, is it? Cause the alchemy, for the most part, is fueled by either tectonic shifts or by "the Dragon's Pulse". NOT DEATH.
Never said I 'hated' it, just didn't find it nearly as good as the first. But, to each his own.
As far as your argument re: alchemy being 'evil', what Hoho is actually referring to is The Three Laws of Thermodynamics, also known as the Principles of Energy. Guess I'm too much of a geek, I enjoyed the fact that somebody may have actually bothered to do some research and find a viable, scientific reason to explain their ideas.
The first law of thermodynamics, also called conservation of energy, states that the total amount of energy in the universe (or system) is constant. This means that all of the energy has to end up somewhere, either in the original form or in a different form (i.e. kinetic or potential or other forms). It cannot be destroyed, only changed into another form. We can use this knowledge to determine the amount of energy in a system.
Everything organic dies, there's just no way of getting around that. But the energy contained in said organic is not lost. It has to end up somewhere. So, according to the first principle and the fact established in the series that the two 'worlds' are linked, Edo and cohorts simply use that energy and change it into another form. The whole idea of the circle makes sense!
Plus, the whole bit with Edo and Winry just creeps me out. Sorry, having had a close friend of opposite sex when I was a kid like that...and to think about a possible 'love' relationship with said friend...*cringe!*...Um...no...that'd be like dating your sister!
But, hey, enjoy 'em both!