Metal Aoi
I love the first one because it was the first anime that I actually finished.
I have my ehs and mehs about brotherhood.
First, I like it because it actually follows the story plot of the manga (Unlike the first one, Although it did have a good twist to it)
The only thing I didn't like was Ed's hair color and the animation style (although I guess I can get used to it T: )
Otherwise they're both good and I don't see why anyone should be complaining.
Sure the first one didn't follow the manga plot, but it gave it and interesting second look at things.
Another thing, I hate it when people debate about the show when they haven't even read the manga.
But Brotherhood is basically the manga :T, and that's why people says it's better. The first anime is different, but it's good in it's own right.
Yeah, I didn't like the animation of Brotherhood :T.