Forever_Rose09
I loved both of them pretty much the same but I feel like Brotherhood rushed through everything too fast. Episode 4 happened in episode 8 of the original plus it was a flashback of when Ed and Al were 11 and 12. Pretty much everything was sadder in the original, but one thing that I loved the most about Brotherhood was the added characters and the whole Xing thing. The ending was kind of predictable and happier but the original was twisted and sad in a way that made me love it because of that twist.
I'm also really sad about the bad rep the original has gotten since Brotherhood came out. I first started watching the show when it was on TV when I was young. I think people need to give it more credit; if it weren't for the original, Brotherhood never would have been created in the first place.
Yeah, the good thing about Brotherhood is the Xing thing and the action, but I'm biased for drama and the first series was also the first anime that made me cry. Man, the Nina episodes broke my heart, just seeing Ed crying, hopeless. That leads me to character development, we really see a change in Ed's actions through the first series: he goes frm vowing to not kill unecesarily to kill a humanoid abomination that was his mother.
I liked the first one better because Ed and Al were such good kids and by the end they're basically messed up, and that's more noticeable there. You're right with Brotherhood's ending.
I know. Just because the first one didn't follow the manga? The later wasn't even finished when they were making the former, even Arakawa asked to come up with an ending because she wasn't even close to finish. Man, the music was beautiful, and Seiji Mizushima's directing was just perfect.