[OFFICIAL]Twilight /NM/ Eclipse Thread: Book Talk~!

NOW which one is your favorite book in the series (after reading Breaking Dawn) ?

Twilight	26.9%	[ 1411 ]
New Moon	8.8%	[ 464 ]
Eclipse	12.8%	[ 671 ]
Breaking Dawn	24.3%	[ 1275 ]
Edward Cullen	10.0%	[ 527 ]
N/A. READ THEM FOR THE LULZ.	17.1%	[ 898 ]
Total Votes:			[ 5246 ]

[Sweet_Violet]

Psychotic Napkin

Sweet_Violet

Car-ma

It's brown.

Does it say that?

Yes.
I reread the first couple of chapters where she describes herself, because I was drawing her. ;D

I re-read it, couldn't find it. Thank you.
It's been bothering me. xd

[Molecular Fruit]

Also, I'm all for Gaspard as Edward, Dennis as Charlie, Daniel Cudmore as Emmett, and Cillian Murphy(omg hawt : D) as James.

[Sweet_Violet]

Psychotic Napkin

Sweet_Violet

I agree with the not changing, she started hesitating at the end of new moon.
She isn't that creative no, but she has to do something creative because it will get really dull if victoria is the only thing going on.
And she can't really bring in the volturi unless someone goes a wee bit nuts.
I love the volturi, they're kick a**.


Being in school's not so bad. I'm in a cabin, on the side of the lake with absolutely nothing....

I think they could do the books justice, but the characters I don't think they could.

Agreed. :nod:
Wait- How do you have a computer if you're in a cabin? o_O Laptop?

I'm not yet, I go in the begining of august, I was meaning I'm in a cabin then.
We could bring the laptop I guess but it probably wouldn't get any internet there.

[Kinara]

Car-ma

I don't think she will change in Eclipse at all. It's way to soon in the series.
Over the whole new vamp...
I don't think SM would do that, because(sorry SM dear) she isn't that creative with her writing. I would ENJOY it though, for Edward to be captivated by the new vampire but still truly care about Bella, and Bella doesn't know that he still cares, as Kin has said. I'd lovelovelove that.

I think I'm in school. Maybe the week before school. Somewhere around that.
Which kind of sucks. Luckily I'm a fast reader so I can finish it before busy school starts.

I do think, if they tried hard, they could do the books great justice. I've seen quite good movies made from books.

I disagree with the whole idea that SM is not creative thing (if she wasn't creative, how would she have written the first two books?), but anyway, I do like the idea of some competition. I'm also hoping that Eclipse has an equal balance of both the dealings of the pack and the vampires. I don't want Ms. Meyer to over-do Edward and Bella because I fear I might get sick of it - and I definitely do not want to get sick of it. gonk

I agree with you, Sweet_Violet, that I'm tentative on whether making a movie for the books is the right thing to do or not. Just look at Eragon. >.>;; It was totally unlike how I imagined it would go. A movie for Twilight would not show the development of Edward and Bella's relationship very well because there is a time limit. It'll probably just rush to the ending which is more action-packed, I guess. That'll make me too depressed. Plus, I don't want the movie to ruin the image I have of the character's in my head.

Oh, and, Sweet_Violet, Bella's eyes are brown. XD It says so like three pages into "New Moon" when she is staring at the mirror in her bathroom, looking at her worry lines, after she has the dream about her birthday. And that was all from memory. God, I'm a creep. .___.;;

[Molecular Fruit]

@Kin: Oh, I never said she wasn't creative, just not creative enough to do that.
I agree. Balance! Twilight was all Edward, New Moon was all Jacob(<3), so Eclipse should be equal.
Haha, I refused to see the Eragon movie.
I'm happy I didn't :}.
I'm loving the idea of a movie. Edward and Bella fell in 'love' PRETTY fast, so I don't think development would be a problem on that. Luckily I'm the type of person who can see a movie based off a book and still imagine the characters the way I want them in my mind C:. Though I'd get angry if they picked bad actors 8D.

@Naps: When do you get out of school for summer?

[Psychotic Napkin]

Car-ma

Also, I'm all for Gaspard as Edward, Dennis as Charlie, Daniel Cudmore as Emmett, and Cillian Murphy(omg hawt : D) as James.

Oh, I should add themm. 3nodding

[Psychotic Napkin]

Sweet_Violet

Psychotic Napkin

Sweet_Violet

I agree with the not changing, she started hesitating at the end of new moon.
She isn't that creative no, but she has to do something creative because it will get really dull if victoria is the only thing going on.
And she can't really bring in the volturi unless someone goes a wee bit nuts.
I love the volturi, they're kick a**.


Being in school's not so bad. I'm in a cabin, on the side of the lake with absolutely nothing....

I think they could do the books justice, but the characters I don't think they could.

Agreed. :nod:
Wait- How do you have a computer if you're in a cabin? o_O Laptop?

I'm not yet, I go in the begining of august, I was meaning I'm in a cabin then.
We could bring the laptop I guess but it probably wouldn't get any internet there.

RIGHT! Me=Dingbat
C:

[Sweet_Violet]

Kinara

Car-ma

I don't think she will change in Eclipse at all. It's way to soon in the series.
Over the whole new vamp...
I don't think SM would do that, because(sorry SM dear) she isn't that creative with her writing. I would ENJOY it though, for Edward to be captivated by the new vampire but still truly care about Bella, and Bella doesn't know that he still cares, as Kin has said. I'd lovelovelove that.

I think I'm in school. Maybe the week before school. Somewhere around that.
Which kind of sucks. Luckily I'm a fast reader so I can finish it before busy school starts.

I do think, if they tried hard, they could do the books great justice. I've seen quite good movies made from books.

I disagree with the whole idea that SM is not creative thing (if she wasn't creative, how would she have written the first two books?), but anyway, I do like the idea of some competition. I'm also hoping that Eclipse has an equal balance of both the dealings of the pack and the vampires. I don't want Ms. Meyer to over-do Edward and Bella because I fear I might get sick of it - and I definitely do not want to get sick of it. gonk

I agree with you, Sweet_Violet, that I'm tentative on whether making a movie for the books is the right thing to do or not. Just look at Eragon. >.>;; It was totally unlike how I imagined it would go. A movie for Twilight would not show the development of Edward and Bella's relationship very well because there is a time limit. It'll probably just rush to the ending which is more action-packed, I guess. That'll make me too depressed. Plus, I don't want the movie to ruin the image I have of the character's in my head.

Oh, and, Sweet_Violet, Bella's eyes are brown. XD It says so like three pages into "New Moon" when she is staring at the mirror in her bathroom, looking at her worry lines, after she has the dream about her birthday. And that was all from memory. God, I'm a creep. .___.;;

I think she loves edward and thats why there is so much of him,
I think there will be more of jacob though, because hes cool.


Eragon was incredibly dissapointing and I haven't even read the book. I think the biggest issue would be pulling off the characters, because you can't describe some things the same way through movies as you can in books.
And yes, it would ruin the image. It's like harry potter. I always thought doby looked like a garden gnome not some freaky little purple thing.

I always pictures her with hazel eyes. My bad I guess.

[Psychotic Napkin]

Car-ma

@Kin: Oh, I never said she wasn't creative, just not creative enough to do that.
I agree. Balance! Twilight was all Edward, New Moon was all Jacob(<3), so Eclipse should be equal.
Haha, I refused to see the Eragon movie.
I'm happy I didn't :}.
I'm loving the idea of a movie. Edward and Bella fell in 'love' PRETTY fast, so I don't think development would be a problem on that. Luckily I'm the type of person who can see a movie based off a book and still imagine the characters the way I want them in my mind C:. Though I'd get angry if they picked bad actors 8D.

@Naps: When do you get out of school for summer?

June 15th

[Molecular Fruit]

Oh~
I get out May 24th and I'm out until the second or third week of august(I think XD).

[Sweet_Violet]

I get out in june and don't get back until september.

[Kinara]

Sweet_Violet

Kinara

Car-ma

I don't think she will change in Eclipse at all. It's way to soon in the series.
Over the whole new vamp...
I don't think SM would do that, because(sorry SM dear) she isn't that creative with her writing. I would ENJOY it though, for Edward to be captivated by the new vampire but still truly care about Bella, and Bella doesn't know that he still cares, as Kin has said. I'd lovelovelove that.

I think I'm in school. Maybe the week before school. Somewhere around that.
Which kind of sucks. Luckily I'm a fast reader so I can finish it before busy school starts.

I do think, if they tried hard, they could do the books great justice. I've seen quite good movies made from books.

I disagree with the whole idea that SM is not creative thing (if she wasn't creative, how would she have written the first two books?), but anyway, I do like the idea of some competition. I'm also hoping that Eclipse has an equal balance of both the dealings of the pack and the vampires. I don't want Ms. Meyer to over-do Edward and Bella because I fear I might get sick of it - and I definitely do not want to get sick of it. gonk

I agree with you, Sweet_Violet, that I'm tentative on whether making a movie for the books is the right thing to do or not. Just look at Eragon. >.>;; It was totally unlike how I imagined it would go. A movie for Twilight would not show the development of Edward and Bella's relationship very well because there is a time limit. It'll probably just rush to the ending which is more action-packed, I guess. That'll make me too depressed. Plus, I don't want the movie to ruin the image I have of the character's in my head.

Oh, and, Sweet_Violet, Bella's eyes are brown. XD It says so like three pages into "New Moon" when she is staring at the mirror in her bathroom, looking at her worry lines, after she has the dream about her birthday. And that was all from memory. God, I'm a creep. .___.;;

I think she loves edward and thats why there is so much of him,
I think there will be more of jacob though, because hes cool.


Eragon was incredibly dissapointing and I haven't even read the book. I think the biggest issue would be pulling off the characters, because you can't describe some things the same way through movies as you can in books.
And yes, it would ruin the image. It's like harry potter. I always thought doby looked like a garden gnome not some freaky little purple thing.

I always pictures her with hazel eyes. My bad I guess.

Haha: Lol at Doby comparison. xD <3 I agree with you on the whole movie thing - now, everytime I read a Harry Potter book, I think of Daniel Radcliffe as Harry or Rupert Grint as Ron. =/ The images I used to have of them are fading, and I hate it. I don't want that to happen with Twilight.

Trust me on Eragon with this one - MUCH better book. One of the best series, but a pretty crappy film in my opinion. I thought they did Saphira all wrong (her voice was okay, but I saw her more like the picture on the front cover of the first book) and I don't believe the person who played Eragon was that good of an actor (kind-of like Daniel Radcliffe). >.>;;

Oh! And on actor choices - personally, I like Chase Crawford the best for Edward and the girl who played Violet in the Series of Unfortunate Events movie for Bella. Otherwise, I need to look for more actors to play other characters. .___.;;;

But I do know one thing for certain - if Dennis Quaid isn't Charlie, I'm going to cry!!! T-T He's so perfect!!

[Sweet_Violet]

Kinara

Sweet_Violet

Kinara

Car-ma

I don't think she will change in Eclipse at all. It's way to soon in the series.
Over the whole new vamp...
I don't think SM would do that, because(sorry SM dear) she isn't that creative with her writing. I would ENJOY it though, for Edward to be captivated by the new vampire but still truly care about Bella, and Bella doesn't know that he still cares, as Kin has said. I'd lovelovelove that.

I think I'm in school. Maybe the week before school. Somewhere around that.
Which kind of sucks. Luckily I'm a fast reader so I can finish it before busy school starts.

I do think, if they tried hard, they could do the books great justice. I've seen quite good movies made from books.

I disagree with the whole idea that SM is not creative thing (if she wasn't creative, how would she have written the first two books?), but anyway, I do like the idea of some competition. I'm also hoping that Eclipse has an equal balance of both the dealings of the pack and the vampires. I don't want Ms. Meyer to over-do Edward and Bella because I fear I might get sick of it - and I definitely do not want to get sick of it. gonk

I agree with you, Sweet_Violet, that I'm tentative on whether making a movie for the books is the right thing to do or not. Just look at Eragon. >.>;; It was totally unlike how I imagined it would go. A movie for Twilight would not show the development of Edward and Bella's relationship very well because there is a time limit. It'll probably just rush to the ending which is more action-packed, I guess. That'll make me too depressed. Plus, I don't want the movie to ruin the image I have of the character's in my head.

Oh, and, Sweet_Violet, Bella's eyes are brown. XD It says so like three pages into "New Moon" when she is staring at the mirror in her bathroom, looking at her worry lines, after she has the dream about her birthday. And that was all from memory. God, I'm a creep. .___.;;

I think she loves edward and thats why there is so much of him,
I think there will be more of jacob though, because hes cool.


Eragon was incredibly dissapointing and I haven't even read the book. I think the biggest issue would be pulling off the characters, because you can't describe some things the same way through movies as you can in books.
And yes, it would ruin the image. It's like harry potter. I always thought doby looked like a garden gnome not some freaky little purple thing.

I always pictures her with hazel eyes. My bad I guess.

Haha: Lol at Doby comparison. xD <3 I agree with you on the whole movie thing - now, everytime I read a Harry Potter book, I think of Daniel Radcliffe as Harry or Rupert Grint as Ron. =/ The images I used to have of them are fading, and I hate it. I don't want that to happen with Twilight.

Trust me on Eragon with this one - MUCH better book. One of the best series, but a pretty crappy film in my opinion. I thought they did Saphira all wrong (her voice was okay, but I saw her more like the picture on the front cover of the first book) and I don't believe the person who played Eragon was that good of an actor (kind-of like Daniel Radcliffe). >.>;;

Oh! And on actor choices - personally, I like Chase Crawford the best for Edward and the girl who played Violet in the Series of Unfortunate Events movie for Bella. Otherwise, I need to look for more actors to play other characters. .___.;;;

But I do know one thing for certain - if Dennis Quaid isn't Charlie, I'm going to cry!!! T-T He's so perfect!!

I actually read harry potter after the first movie came out so they were already harry and ron for me, but everything introduced afterwards like doby and sirus, they totally ruined for me. And they took so much out it destroyed it.

And everyone says eragon is a much better book, I've never read it because my friend kept shoving it at me, I didn't want to please him I guess.

I like Gaspard for edward, he looks the part. I agree with Jesse Spencer for carlisle, And also with Dennis Quaid as charlie.

You can call me Violet, btw.

[Devaki~Kao]

So the movie is deffinite(sp?) then?

[Sweet_Violet]

Devaki~Kao

So the movie is deffinite(sp?) then?

I don't think it's definite, but a possibility.