TheTonberryKing
Ever hear the expression "Hindsite is 20/20 In Rose Colored Glasses"?
I'm convinced that people are still stuck in 1997, when they were brain washed by the media into beleiving FFVII was some wonderful thing, and the impression has stuck with them all these years.
I look back and I see poorly designed pre-rendered backgrounds that were cluttered and lacked proper resolution, sub standard midi-quality sountrack, shoddy, chunky programing and a poor localization job to boot.
I won't argue about the story, but you cannot tell me those graphics were beautiful by any standard, nor the music fantastic. It was good because nothing else was around that was 3D. It didn't mean it was done well.
This magic feeling you talk about is totaly in your head, and as long as you keep fearing it not to be there in anything new, its not GOING to be there. Its self-fulfilled destiny.
Oh, but aren't the magic feeling of stuff ALWAYS in your head, regardless of whether it is from awe gained by seeing the beauty of the Niagara falls, or the game FFVII?
I can't say I can see my own opinions in the ones you state above. I played VII when I was 14 years old, i.e. 4 years ago. And though I had played games with far greater graphic, more beautiful rendering, nicer programming and a better localizations job before I ever got my hands on VII, I
STILL experienced that magical feeling when playing. I fell in love with the characters, the background images, the storyline, and the music. Sure, it wasn't the most beautiful game I ever played, but when playing X a year later, I didn't find that magical touch VII had. I can't see how that can be nostalgia, or media tricking my mind into believeing it to be greater than it is. I can't say I heard of the game before I set my eyes on it, since I didn't read gaming magazines back when it was released. None of the people in my closest surrounding was interested in videogames, so....
FFVII is just magical for some people. I am one of them.