AkaneShinigami
(?)Community Member
Offline
- Report Post
- Posted: Sun, 22 Jan 2012 02:49:54 +0000
Dark Rogue Hellord
AkaneShinigami
Dark Rogue Hellord
AkaneShinigami
Dark Rogue Hellord
I admit that the Silver theory is a wee bit far-fetched (obligatory duck picture here), but after hearing the Oak theories I'd believe anything else. My game corner coins are still on the Giovanni bet, personally. There's a lot more believable ideas and suggestions than there are points against it, if any. I'd also argue that divorce is a little too heavy for the Pokemon anime as it is right now, but then Brock's parents come to mind and... yeah.
Thanks again for quoting, and yeah, the Silver theory is kinda out there. I don't know about you but I am a little tiny bit skeptical about the Oak theory. Just a tiny bit. I personally think that Prof. Oak wouldn't have an affair with a women so young, his star pupil at that, and the approximate timeline of Ash's birth would mean that he'd been cheating on his wife all the way until her death. I don't think Oak is a cheater, also, he showed much more interest in Gary that his supposed 'son' in the first episode. So, yeah, you putting all your money on Giovanni is smart, you might just get you're Porygon yet. xd
Also, though I don't really give this much thought, there is the possibility that Ash may have either been adopted or Delia had had an artificial insemination. But I doubt it.
I'm used to hitting the reply button instead of the quote button, gomen.
As far as genetics go I don't think Ash looks even the tiniest bit like Oak or even Gary. There's a thought, he's lifelong rivals with his uncle. xD Out of his supposed fathers he looks more like Giovanni, but then none of those dads have black hair either which allows for some other possibilities I guess.
That's funny, if that is the case, and I highly doubt it, I think Ash would have Gary pony up for all those years of calling him a 'loser'. Smell you later, indeed. biggrin
Also the black hair could have easily been a recessive gene carried by both Delia and Giovanni. Just a thought, but really that could be true.
Something I've noticed is that one's uncle is always either a really funny guy or a big jerk. Weird that way, but Gary would at least get points for falling into the appropriate category. Geeze, Pallet Town is seriously messed up, huh? xd
I thought about the recessive gene idea, but I don't know how often those happen in anime of any kind. Even kid's shows unless the main character has unnatural hair and whatnot, but that's a separate argument entirely.
You're right, in anime, if you're dad has purple hair and so does your mom, than gosh darndit, so do you! Anime's are fun like that, but there also annoying that way when you're trying to prove your fanon-theory.
You're right about the recessive gene thing, it is very unlikely, but it could happen. More or less, I'm always going to think that Giovanni is Ash's dad. So yeah, I'mma be throwing out counter's to everybody's 'attacks' at my headcannon. xd But it's a little bit obvious that they might be related, they have similar facial features and Ash even has a little bit of a condescending streak. Just a little bit, because we all know that Delia raised him sweet. That's why he's such a push-over now.