My Dog Mr. Kitty
Tiffyish
My Dog Mr. Kitty
Tiffyish
My Dog Mr. Kitty
Tiffyish
While I don't dispute much of what you've said, only the success rate in suicides is higher in men. Females attempt it at about a 2:1 ratio (sorry, accidentally exited that source) but men succeed more because they attempt more "foolproof" methods, like hanging/
shooting, at least in the US. I'm not sure that suicide/suicide attempt is relevant to this discussion.
The same source states that 72-89% of women who committed suicide had been speaking to a mental health professional, only 41-58% of men who committed suicide had. That shows the societal tendency to understand women with depression, but to make light of men with it as simply needing to man up
I don't think it's societal tendency to understand ANYBODY with depression. I would need to look more closely at statistics involving people asking for help in any subject, as well as men accepting help that is offered. If there's a discrepancy between genders, I could see placing the blame on a society that forces men to be masculine (and dictates what defines 'masculine'). But one could also claim that a discrepancy could be the result of women being looked at as people who need help, people that need to be cared for, and people who cannot do things on their own (rather than a problem of men being pressured into their societal norms). Good lord, what a multi-faceted topic.
As I've said, there's issues on both sides of the gender equation
Yeah, depression is largely misunderstood by people, but think about reactions of society between a woman crying and a man crying. The woman is consoled and asked what's wrong, the man is told to get over it and be a man. Being someone with severe anxiety issues, who's own mother has the same issues told him that he should get over it and be a man, it's debilitating. I can't imagine the impact something like that would have on a man with depression
I feel that's an over-generalization; depression is not about crying. Depression can be rearing its ugly head in people who appear to be happy and healthy. While it may be more common for people to stop and console a woman stranger who is crying than it would be for them to stop for a man stranger, it's not relevant to how depression functions or how people respond when they hear others have depression. That's why I believe depression/suicide irrelevant to this specific topic about how men and women are treated differently in society, mostly because all people of all genders with mental illnesses are treated differently than those without, anyway. I'm sorry you have to put up with that bullshit from your own mother.
I know that people are viewed differently when they get diagnosed with depression, but the perceptions between the genders when they get depression are different. Because one gender is largely viewed by society as wanting/needing to be taken care of and the other is viewed as needing to be strong and hide emotion, showing a weakness such as having diagnosed depression is perceived differently
The depression issue on gender was really only meant as a single example of why women have it easier in some ways than men. I never meant it to be a defining issue or the subject of a long discussion
Oh, my bad.
That's true, and I suppose those gender roles could be blamed on a patriarchal foundation of society. This subject is always very confusing to me because where is the line drawn? Is one the result of the other? Women are seen as weak because they have always been largely housewives and women of work in more feminine jobs up until late last century. Men could be seen as not being allowed to show weakness, or fear, BECAUSE they're "supposed" to care for the women. What can be done to stop the cycle? I feel as though the issues of expected masculinity and femininity very heavily overlap, which is why I've never identified as a "feminist." However, I do support a lot of what feminists fight for, because to gain equality takes small steps. I feel that every win for feminists would also prove positive to anybody who argues for "men's rights" (and, you know, aren't the whiny brats that 'MRA's are described as) because it's one step closer to balance. When a feminist claims that she rejects society's idea that she needs to shave her legs/arms/underarms/whatever to be viewed as beautiful, or even that she needs to be seen as beautiful, it's also a win for the man who shaves his legs. Because the less we associate things with genders (the idea that it is feminine, or the idea that crying is feminine), even if the original focus was on women, the less the opposite will be associated in men. If we stop defining things as feminine, what is defined as masculine won't have an opposite. As much as a woman has a right to equal pay or to have a man stop ogling her in public, a man has the right to wear make-up or throw on a skirt. Though, it seems as though women have to catch up to where men are, before tearing down societal norms.
I guess what I think I'm saying is that the main problem with society is viewing things as this or that, male or female, feminine or masculine. I don't really have a solid train of thought here, my apologies.