Riviera de la Mancha
(?)Community Member
- Report Post
- Posted: Sat, 27 Oct 2012 05:43:26 +0000
low iq 111
Riviera de la Mancha
First, you need to justify this notion that the rich have responsibilities by virtue of being rich.
like i said in another post, "really?"
what you're asking for is like asking someone to prove that it's wrong to be a child abuser... it's not exactly proven by science or anything but it will make a society better if the rich give their stuff too other people or other life forms. why? because we need to start making sure all humans have what they need and then after that we should be promoting life and growth on our world. why? because the earth is one of the rare places that supports life and we as humans should try and allow as many lifeforms and precious things have a chance to live. why, again, you ask? because that is the right thing to do. and i am 'pro-life'.
What you are talking about is a general duty to others. I am asking what exactly about being rich creates, by itself, a duty to others. The OP makes it clear that there is something by virtue of being wealthy that makes rich people beholden to others to perform all the tasks, or some combination thereof, that the OP mentions.
What I believe is that we all, rich or poor, have a duty to others, and part of fulfilling that duty is paying taxes, in proportion to your income, to provide services society deems important. In my opinion, there is nothing about being wealthy that makes you immune to this responsibility generally, or somehow means you alone get to decide how your money is spent for tax purposes for no other reason than you are wealthy.