feralenvelope
astroius
Maid 0f Time
Tipsy Fatcat
9,300 Points
-
150
-
100
-
200
i personally really enjoy the series
i haven't seen the third season yet, but i definitely loved the way that the first two seasons made you think
like, you almost never see the twist coming and there's always something to think about while watching these crimes unfold
seeing things through sherlock's eyes and mindset is fascinating in and of itself and i really enjoy the cinematography
idk it's kind of brainy and it makes you think so if you like puzzling shows that are also enjoyable to watch i would say try it out!
each episode is an hour and a half long, however, so be prepared to set aside some time to watch this series lmao
i haven't seen the third season yet, but i definitely loved the way that the first two seasons made you think
like, you almost never see the twist coming and there's always something to think about while watching these crimes unfold
seeing things through sherlock's eyes and mindset is fascinating in and of itself and i really enjoy the cinematography
idk it's kind of brainy and it makes you think so if you like puzzling shows that are also enjoyable to watch i would say try it out!
each episode is an hour and a half long, however, so be prepared to set aside some time to watch this series lmao
QueenAceofSpades
kamidrgn
Dapper Genius
9,000 Points
-
200
-
200
-
100
Nuclear Muchacho
Super Cyclops
koweja
Fluffy Genius
7,400 Points
-
200
-
100
-
200
.
I actually prefer Elementary to Sherlock.
Sherlock season 1 was brilliant. Season 2 was still very good. Whoa, what a let down season 3 was. Unless you are a massive massive Johnlock shipper and enjoy picking up on all the little Johnlock stuff (which a lot of the fans do enjoy doing), there was not much good about the season. The third episode was fairly good, the ending was very interesting (not going to say much else), but the first two episodes you have to sit through, my God, such a let down after the first two seasons. They could have been worse, but they weren't even in the same league as the other seasons and that was just really disappointing to me.
You might feel very differently - a lot of people do.
In my opinion, Elementary is more consistent. They've changed things about the plot and the characters, and Watson in particular really shines in this show. The character doesn't exist to just prove how clever Sherlock is. Some people argue that they chose to make Watson female because they "didn't want a gay relationship between Sherlock and Watson!!", but I really think the decision was made to even out the genders in the cast.
Sherlock in Elementary is gifted, but other characters have a chance to be intelligent too. The plot doesn't solely revolve around Sherlock showing people how stupid the other characters are and constantly proving his superior intellect.
I really don't understand why the show isn't more popular.
HOWEVER, the cases in BBC Sherlock are consistently *far* better than those in Elementary, and BBC Sherlock's mind palace is awesome and the effects are top notch.
Yes, I would recommend watching Sherlock, but I personally prefer Elementary.
I actually prefer Elementary to Sherlock.
Sherlock season 1 was brilliant. Season 2 was still very good. Whoa, what a let down season 3 was. Unless you are a massive massive Johnlock shipper and enjoy picking up on all the little Johnlock stuff (which a lot of the fans do enjoy doing), there was not much good about the season. The third episode was fairly good, the ending was very interesting (not going to say much else), but the first two episodes you have to sit through, my God, such a let down after the first two seasons. They could have been worse, but they weren't even in the same league as the other seasons and that was just really disappointing to me.
You might feel very differently - a lot of people do.
In my opinion, Elementary is more consistent. They've changed things about the plot and the characters, and Watson in particular really shines in this show. The character doesn't exist to just prove how clever Sherlock is. Some people argue that they chose to make Watson female because they "didn't want a gay relationship between Sherlock and Watson!!", but I really think the decision was made to even out the genders in the cast.
Sherlock in Elementary is gifted, but other characters have a chance to be intelligent too. The plot doesn't solely revolve around Sherlock showing people how stupid the other characters are and constantly proving his superior intellect.
I really don't understand why the show isn't more popular.
HOWEVER, the cases in BBC Sherlock are consistently *far* better than those in Elementary, and BBC Sherlock's mind palace is awesome and the effects are top notch.
Yes, I would recommend watching Sherlock, but I personally prefer Elementary.
knightofthe21stcentury
shenavyre
Dangerous Hunter
5,700 Points
-
100
-
100
-
100
Crowryl
Angelic Man-Lover
22,625 Points
-
100
-
100
koweja
.
I actually prefer Elementary to Sherlock.
Sherlock season 1 was brilliant. Season 2 was still very good. Whoa, what a let down season 3 was. Unless you are a massive massive Johnlock shipper and enjoy picking up on all the little Johnlock stuff (which a lot of the fans do enjoy doing), there was not much good about the season. The third episode was fairly good, the ending was very interesting (not going to say much else), but the first two episodes you have to sit through, my God, such a let down after the first two seasons. They could have been worse, but they weren't even in the same league as the other seasons and that was just really disappointing to me.
You might feel very differently - a lot of people do.
In my opinion, Elementary is more consistent. They've changed things about the plot and the characters, and Watson in particular really shines in this show. The character doesn't exist to just prove how clever Sherlock is. Some people argue that they chose to make Watson female because they "didn't want a gay relationship between Sherlock and Watson!!", but I really think the decision was made to even out the genders in the cast.
Sherlock in Elementary is gifted, but other characters have a chance to be intelligent too. The plot doesn't solely revolve around Sherlock showing people how stupid the other characters are and constantly proving his superior intellect.
I really don't understand why the show isn't more popular.
HOWEVER, the cases in BBC Sherlock are consistently *far* better than those in Elementary, and BBC Sherlock's mind palace is awesome and the effects are top notch.
Yes, I would recommend watching Sherlock, but I personally prefer Elementary.
I actually prefer Elementary to Sherlock.
Sherlock season 1 was brilliant. Season 2 was still very good. Whoa, what a let down season 3 was. Unless you are a massive massive Johnlock shipper and enjoy picking up on all the little Johnlock stuff (which a lot of the fans do enjoy doing), there was not much good about the season. The third episode was fairly good, the ending was very interesting (not going to say much else), but the first two episodes you have to sit through, my God, such a let down after the first two seasons. They could have been worse, but they weren't even in the same league as the other seasons and that was just really disappointing to me.
You might feel very differently - a lot of people do.
In my opinion, Elementary is more consistent. They've changed things about the plot and the characters, and Watson in particular really shines in this show. The character doesn't exist to just prove how clever Sherlock is. Some people argue that they chose to make Watson female because they "didn't want a gay relationship between Sherlock and Watson!!", but I really think the decision was made to even out the genders in the cast.
Sherlock in Elementary is gifted, but other characters have a chance to be intelligent too. The plot doesn't solely revolve around Sherlock showing people how stupid the other characters are and constantly proving his superior intellect.
I really don't understand why the show isn't more popular.
HOWEVER, the cases in BBC Sherlock are consistently *far* better than those in Elementary, and BBC Sherlock's mind palace is awesome and the effects are top notch.
Yes, I would recommend watching Sherlock, but I personally prefer Elementary.
I'm not tryin' to be rude, just wanting to point out some facts. I'm not sure if you ever have bothered to read the Sherlock books, but they are literally from Watsons point of view. The books are literally evolved around the brilliance and life of Sherlock and how much John praises him, yadda yadda.
Johnlock has been a thing since the books came out.
So there is BBC Sherlock that is pretty close to the books and modern time, and then there is Elementary, which I have no idea what they are even doing because I found it dumb.
Johnlock has been a thing since the books came out.
So there is BBC Sherlock that is pretty close to the books and modern time, and then there is Elementary, which I have no idea what they are even doing because I found it dumb.
koweja
Fluffy Genius
7,400 Points
-
200
-
100
-
200
Crowryl
koweja
.
I actually prefer Elementary to Sherlock.
Sherlock season 1 was brilliant. Season 2 was still very good. Whoa, what a let down season 3 was. Unless you are a massive massive Johnlock shipper and enjoy picking up on all the little Johnlock stuff (which a lot of the fans do enjoy doing), there was not much good about the season. The third episode was fairly good, the ending was very interesting (not going to say much else), but the first two episodes you have to sit through, my God, such a let down after the first two seasons. They could have been worse, but they weren't even in the same league as the other seasons and that was just really disappointing to me.
You might feel very differently - a lot of people do.
In my opinion, Elementary is more consistent. They've changed things about the plot and the characters, and Watson in particular really shines in this show. The character doesn't exist to just prove how clever Sherlock is. Some people argue that they chose to make Watson female because they "didn't want a gay relationship between Sherlock and Watson!!", but I really think the decision was made to even out the genders in the cast.
Sherlock in Elementary is gifted, but other characters have a chance to be intelligent too. The plot doesn't solely revolve around Sherlock showing people how stupid the other characters are and constantly proving his superior intellect.
I really don't understand why the show isn't more popular.
HOWEVER, the cases in BBC Sherlock are consistently *far* better than those in Elementary, and BBC Sherlock's mind palace is awesome and the effects are top notch.
Yes, I would recommend watching Sherlock, but I personally prefer Elementary.
I actually prefer Elementary to Sherlock.
Sherlock season 1 was brilliant. Season 2 was still very good. Whoa, what a let down season 3 was. Unless you are a massive massive Johnlock shipper and enjoy picking up on all the little Johnlock stuff (which a lot of the fans do enjoy doing), there was not much good about the season. The third episode was fairly good, the ending was very interesting (not going to say much else), but the first two episodes you have to sit through, my God, such a let down after the first two seasons. They could have been worse, but they weren't even in the same league as the other seasons and that was just really disappointing to me.
You might feel very differently - a lot of people do.
In my opinion, Elementary is more consistent. They've changed things about the plot and the characters, and Watson in particular really shines in this show. The character doesn't exist to just prove how clever Sherlock is. Some people argue that they chose to make Watson female because they "didn't want a gay relationship between Sherlock and Watson!!", but I really think the decision was made to even out the genders in the cast.
Sherlock in Elementary is gifted, but other characters have a chance to be intelligent too. The plot doesn't solely revolve around Sherlock showing people how stupid the other characters are and constantly proving his superior intellect.
I really don't understand why the show isn't more popular.
HOWEVER, the cases in BBC Sherlock are consistently *far* better than those in Elementary, and BBC Sherlock's mind palace is awesome and the effects are top notch.
Yes, I would recommend watching Sherlock, but I personally prefer Elementary.
I'm not tryin' to be rude, just wanting to point out some facts. I'm not sure if you ever have bothered to read the Sherlock books, but they are literally from Watsons point of view. The books are literally evolved around the brilliance and life of Sherlock and how much John praises him, yadda yadda.
Johnlock has been a thing since the books came out.
So there is BBC Sherlock that is pretty close to the books and modern time, and then there is Elementary, which I have no idea what they are even doing because I found it dumb.
Johnlock has been a thing since the books came out.
So there is BBC Sherlock that is pretty close to the books and modern time, and then there is Elementary, which I have no idea what they are even doing because I found it dumb.
.
You don't sound rude at all c:
I am aware that the Sherlock books are indeed from Watson's point of view, and that they centre around brilliant Sherlock is - although I haven't read them all (and that was a few years ago). Even then I found it annoying that Watson's character seemed only to exist in order to question how Sherlock knew everything.
BBC Sherlock is closer to the books, and I do like that about it, as well as the cases are far better, like I said. However, I admire Elementary's efforts to change things about the original and I also prefer it not being centered around Sherlock.
It is more of a personal preference, and I definitely understand that some people like BBC Sherlock more, and I can understand their reasons for doing so.
I hope I didn't come across as sounding like I was completely disregarding BBC Sherlock or the books
Hiddled
Pixar Lamp
Akaru Renuji
XxXAurora BorealisXxX
Tipsy Hero