CelestialChild
Iron Geek
smrtness
Iron Geek
It's like Battle Royale except no-one learns anything and it's intensely boring as well as squandering an excellent premise.
"It's like Battle Royale" = code words of everyone who has never read all of the books.
This isn't about the books, dear. It's a bland film where the protagonist learns nothing; even in Clerks the main character learns something and that's essentially a film about nothing. This has an excellent premise and turns it into a 2 hour slog.
Though I will concede that than one bit where she threw up the three finger salute and everyone rioted was great.
But otherwise zzzz.
Why does it have to be a story about "learning something"? What exactly were you expecting her to learn? Why does it make it boring that she didn't learn something if she had nothing to learn?
Because that's how stories work; the character starts off in one place and through his or her arc ends up in a completely different place spiritually, emotionally etc. But here we know she's brave, passionate, noble and such and she closes out the movie the way she came into it, it's dull.
She's got a family depending on her back home she should have shanked that other kid the moment she found out that only one of them was going home. Instead we see that she doesn't really have to sacrifice to go home, she gets an easy out.
If a character has nothing to learn, if there's no room for change then that character is two dimensional and not particularly interesting to watch for 10 minutes let alone 2 hours.