Zero the Crimson
I don't know how you can Nerf someone with no powers or someone who's suppose to be pretty much invincible yet time and time again gets wailed and walloped upon by people with minor powers or people who happen to have his "one" weakness...which is a rock?
1. You forgot to mention that the first someone has no powers except "writer bias" which allows him to magically be able to beat anyone and anything even though it's completely stupid and unrealistic even in a world where costumed super-powered people are taken with a straight face.
2. That second someone usually isn't supposed to be invincible, and he's not usually walloped upon by people with minor powers unless "writer bias" kicks in, which happens to be a weakness for him because as much as people hate on Aquaman for dumb reasons, Superman's just as likely to get hated and misunderstood.
Why the hate on characters like these? Easy: it's popular. People just parrot what they hear others say so they can seem smart. It doesn't help that this negative stereotyping has invaded mainstream media too, with folks like Tarantino who
completely misunderstands Superman as a character rambling about him from time to time in various movies, and shows like
Family Guy using Aquaman as a punchline several times.
Like I said, the hate is just a popularity thing, and it's rather pathetic. Most unfortunate is that this kind of s**t has cropped up in the offices of DC and the people who license DC characters. Even they have a hard time liking Superman and Aquaman, and it's only because golden boy Geoff Johns happens to dig Aquaman that he's had any kind of popularity revival. Once he's off the title, Aquaman will probably go back in the shitter. If his name's not Batman, DC doesn't usually like to keep top writers and artists on a character for too long. They'd rather send them out to do crap like
Before Watchmen.