I think a little more research needs to be done.....I'm not an expert myself, but I will relay what I do know.
First of all, as a Christian, I fully believe that the Earth was created in six days, and that there is a God and He loves us all. That aside...
Actually, the physical evidence that we evolved is rather weak. Now, there is also not a lot of evidence that supports creation, which means that we will never actually know the truth until we die. If we end up in heaven....oops, I guess we were created. If nothing happens, well, I won't know the difference. I'll be dead.
Much of this evidence that has been found just doesn't fit a lot of the principals and theories. There was an instance of an ancient human finger that was found. It was found at the Commanche Peak, not far from the Paluxy riverbed, in cretaceous gravels. An amazing find, yes. However, there is a slight problem. What were humans doing in the cretaceous period? It just doesn't make sense. Many of these rocks formed in the different ages don't line up. Things are being found in all the wrong places (whale fossils on mountain tops) and in the wrong time periods.
Of course, this is one example of many. Again, I'm not a scholar, I just happen to be slightly passionate and I've been to a few seminars...
But again, it is something that will never be resolved, as long as humanity exists.