CRITIQUING THE WINNERS! Retiring - Thank you, everyone. <3

[Nostalgia Critic]

Your return is almost like Christmas to me.

[Irie Kyousuke]

ILY PIKA.
I'm glad you finally came back. 8D
Maybe this time you won't troll. talk2hand (just kidding)

[MyDino]

I missed you,even though it's only been a week.Welcome back.<3 You almost gave me a heart attack oAo

[Erithan]

Welcome back! 3nodding

[Valgaror]

YOU'RE BACK. 8D

I'm on the throne when you're down on your knees
I'm not a cure, I'm a ******** disease
A brand new name for a brand new revolution
We are a problem, we are not a solution

[cuvier]

Welcome back Pika!

[RenkonNairu]

Pikachew

This is the best cosplay of an azz I have ever seen. Honestly if those cheeks were in a line-up I'd be able to point to these and go "My God that's Mai's gluteus maximus!" The face doesn't mean anything and the detail behind the umbrella is purely irrelevant when it comes to cosplaying Mai. According to gaia, a 180 degree turn is the same as a three quarter turn! Genius! Next week I'll enter as Peter Giffin's belly button! YEAH! 2/5

I'm disappointed in you, 'Chew. I was expecting far more "butt" jokes. Especially since I came in 10th, I came in behind everyone else. Such a pity.

[Leafy XIII Hope XIII]

nice critiques

[MiniDaai]

∂ααι ѕαуѕ:________________________________________________________________________
»☆_Winks everywhere!! scream
The same thing I said
THANKS A LOT FOR COMING BACK, PIKACHEW YOU'VE MADE MY DAY!!

[Superkrad]

Welcome back.
I loved the Buu avatar this week, it was a nice surprise.

[rio_kid]

OK first, I want to say I love your avatar Pikachew.

Next, I disagree with what you said about the avatar that placed number 2, Peter Griffin in the Never Ending story. What other items that can make you look fat and not show a gut? What other item makes a dragon look like it's struggling? He's tried his best using the items available. And this is what gave this avatar it's creativeness. If you know an item that doies those things, Great! that avatar could've been better. That's all. I do agree with the spelling & hair though. Great Reviews BTW.

[rio_kid]

I also disagree with the Saw entry. That avatar was well done. I don't know what you meant with your opinion on this avatar, but please explain why this avatar deserved a 2? I want to know.

[le artista]

wanders in. wow. this week was pretty bad. thanks for the enjoyable critique.

did the old thread get deleted? strange. well kinda like the new leaner thread anyway.

[Superkrad]

rio_kid

I also disagree with the Saw entry. That avatar was well done. I don't know what you meant with your opinion on this avatar, but please explain why this avatar deserved a 2? I want to know.

I agree with this guy, the Saw entry was well done.

[Pikachew]

Nostalgia Critic: If my coming back is like Christmas, does that make every roll-over in the arenas April Fools? wink


RenkonNairu: I didn't mean to fart on your entry and give you a toot out of five. I don't do puns, but I do do buns.


rio_kid: Thank you

The best possible items available for most cosplays aren't always the best looking. Peter is an example of doing the best you can with what gaia has to offer, but still coming up short. I think the cosplayer knew that his Peter wasn't perfect, but entered anyway because he liked it and thought others would as well. There are no better alternatives unless you want a skinny Peter standing in a white void without a dragon. His creativity saved him. Without it, he would've been a dead 1.

The Saw doll has his sleeves lifted, is bald at the top (gaia has no hairstyle for that), and has a closed jacket. Just like Peter, it's ok, but before its time. I gave it a two? I meant to give it a 3. xp

Thank you for all the welcome back-a-lacks. They mean a lot. Moo moo moo. I love you? xp