Mortane
Rhiannon Chandra
N'mol: If they were meant to exist, they would be able to hatch on their own. They aren't strong enough to come in to the world on their own. Therefore, they're unnatural.
Hekate: Well if you're going by that logic then humans are also unnatural to Pern and shouldn't exist here. Also by that logic so are both Benden's Queens since it was only through the unnatural application of mystweed that they were born what with Benden's declining gold laying rate.
N'mol: *Stares at Hekate* You're purposely misunderstanding what I'm saying, and I understand that as a Silverrider this isn't what you want to hear. We aren't
native to Pern, but we aren't unnatural. If we were, our species never would have evolved enough to make it to traveling the stars. Also, all of the Weyrs were struggling with laying Golds-- some more than others, yes-- but mystweed was applied to ALL of the Queens, not just Benden's. If the claim you just made was true it would make your Silver even more unnatural, as well as claiming that any dragon born
naturally from an egg in the last year or so was also unnatural.
But, you're forgetting that mystweed is natural to their diets. The plant died out because it was useful in treating plague and was overharvested. If it hadn't been, the dragons would never have suffered infertility in the first place. It is natural for them. But with or without mystweed, Flights would occur and the dragons who are strong enough to come into the world would hatch from their eggs. Mystweed doesn't change if a dragon is strong or not. I'm talking about survival. Atypicals only began coming out-- if the Whiterider will please forgive me for pointing this out-- when people began 'worrying' about dragons who were too weak to hatch. In nature, no one hatches atypical eggs. You'll only ever see them in the Weyrs. And they are, for the first Turn or more of their lives, a problem. It takes five times the resources to help raise an atypical dragon to adulthood as it does a normal dragon. I won't argue about their skills as adults; I'm sure that your dragon when trained and placed in a wing will perform like any other dragon. I'm talking about whether or not they would make it that far without all of the aid you give them in hatching and then just trying to live. Honestly, it is incredible to me that as many of them survive as they do, considering how prone to sickness they are as Weyrlings. However, I know that that is due to the efforts and strength of their riders, not their own strength.
((@Thali-- Lol I thought of that. But they've been around for so long that they've become part of Pern. People don't think of them that way. And N'mol is making an argument for 'survival of the fittest.' Other than the choking-on-meat thing and the desire for oil on cracked hide, baby dragons can easily survive on their own. Atypicals, not so much. You have to be careful with food, extra careful with their hide, they get cold easily, they're too weak to walk very far on their own. In N'mol's mind, that's justification for Benden's stance on atyps, which is what he was raised with. There is room to change his mind on it, he's young yet, but there has to be proof or he's never going to buy it. And this is all very OOC. He would
never get into this conversation in real life. He doesn't think of himself as being prejudiced.))