Phantomhorse1810
I will be truthful, I hated it. It mixed the books together in such an odd way and Jack was all wrong somehow. Expecially his voice. My largest problem is how all of the book characters in it seemed wrong and not how I wanted them, but this is just my feel. A poor attempt at a sequel for the first movie and a poor way of putting two books together.
How about you?
I have mixed feelings about that movie. I thought the effects were very good for the year the film was made, and I did like that they were trying to be a little more true to the books than the original. (Mentioning the Deadly Desert, Dorothy being the proper age, the Lion being an actual lion and not a man in a suit... And my favorite, Dorothy actually telling the story of how the Tin Woodsman came to be... Stuff like that.)
At the same time, I agree with you, it did mix up book two and three very strangely, and I hate,
hate what they did with Mombi and the Nome King. I actually really love the Nome King in the books, (or rather, Roquat the Red. ^^) and don't like what they did with him at all.
They also took many aspects from the original movie, that I just hated... Her real life leaking over into her 'dream' of Oz, (which was never a dream in the first place... >.< ) and waking up at the end only to find that it was all just a dream. And Ozma wasn't right.
scream There was no Tip, and she turned out to just be a metephor for Dorothy's longing to stay in her dream world of Oz.
Again, I have mixed feelings about it. All I can say is that although they messed up so many things and screwed it up so royally, at least it was closer to the books than the original movie. XD
Which is sad, lol