Maybe a rate for how obvious it is what you're going for,
and perhaps how well that was pulled off,
or why it was/wasn't obvious?
In the productive section.
So maybe like, "I couldn't really tell you were going for
a half and half avatar.
It just looked like clutter to me."
I dunno, something like that. xD
Probably be a good rate for themes, style, and characters.
edit ::
Also a Tektek suggestion rate maybe?
(Not intended for tekteks, but for real avatars.)
Someone posts a tektek of an avatar they want suggestions for,
maybe their current or just something they're working on,
and the rater goes on tektek and messes around with it.
Adds a few items, takes off a few.
It'd be similar to receiving specific item suggestions
except that they're actually added on
so everyone can see how they look.
More work, but maybe it'd be interesting? xD