Welcome to Gaia! :: CRITIQUING THE WINNERS! WEEK 48: S.I.N lost this round. | Forum

Register FaceBook Login Login

 

 
GST

Welcome to Gaia's forums, where millions of members gather to discuss random stuff, make new friends,
complain about life, argue about nothing, laugh at dumb pictures, discuss serious issues and/or curse like sailors.

Lurking is creepy. Quit skulking in the shadows and join the conversation!

Register to reply

Advertisement
Tags: critiquing  winners  arena  pokemon 
Share:  
forum:154, topic:54214421
< 1 2 ... 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 ... 54 55 56 > >>
I have to say, this is my favorite critique thread. You explain things better then the other (plus add a pic of the avi's in question) and I think you also do better job of saying what could be improved.
 
     
 
Welcome back Pikachew 3nodding
     
He smokes syringes is the greatest line I've ever read.
 
     
I was,
am, and
always will be,

Whisperingsorrow.
 
Sky of the Silver Ocean
I was surprised to see the Dread Pirate Roberts cosplay. I adore that movie, so I would judge it very harshly myself, by it was oddly good...the hair seems a little off even though it can hardly be seen. I think that the Westley cosplay made this week almost worth it. <3

I did have a hard time with the hair, the head-shape made any protrusion from the back extra noticable, and Gaia doesn't really have a tiny ponytail option, so I stripped it down to bare bones. I'm glad you liked it otherwise, though. Thinking about taking a swing at Inigo next week on the other side of the duel. mrgreen
     
( '_')
You are the Perez Hilton of gaia lol...I must admit the reason I stay away from Avatar Arena's is i'm scared of people like you shooting down an entry, but it is intresting to see what you write...Ty for the random that linked me this page
 
     

Happy Halloween!
     
 
Hi Pikachew, long time no talk. Im putting myself into the arena's for week 39. Hope I win so I can get one of your great critiques p:
     

http://i25.tinypic.com/11bq6ok.jpg
Click the sad faces to go to my art request thread.
Click the "Tap my tank" to go to my recycled aquarium thread if you see me glow, post? :]
Awesome sigmap shop
I love you Seth, hope your eternal sleep is a good one.
Dread Pirate Roberts deserved 1st place.
 
     








"Draw me with Roark. I tip well."
 
yay you are back heart i only look for you to read since yours is the most understandable and funny
     
yesterday is history...

tomorrow is a mystery...

but today is a gift...thats why they call it a *present*


I really hope week 39 is awesome... seriously...
 
     

It's me in mouse form!
Thanks to TwilekJedi for the avi art!
 
So, I may be a tad late but..

HOLYFUZZINGCRAP heart
Pikachew, you never fail to make me smile. wink
Welcome back! I was starting to forget about the Arena.. xD

I thought 1st place was awesome. It totally deserved 1st place. :]
And I squealed a little when I saw Wesley. whee
     
OH MY BOY, if you don't make a choice in the end
i don't know how you'll cope when they feed you all their lies

You left twice and then you came back again! YAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I haven't been posting in a while, but I have been lurking. I'm so so so so happy you're back to making the arenas fun! I missed you! I was about to explode if you didn't pop up last week.

That dragonair has got to the crappiest thing I've ever seen. Stupid crazy pokemon fans and 2008-2009 newbs. They know nothing about cosplaying.
 
     
MagicTate481
 

[♦] [♥] [♦]
▬ ▬ ▬ ▬ ▬



OMFG WHAT IS THAT SME---or it's Chew's head.Anyway,quoted for emphasis from the other thread I posted in:
Quote:

Lolz,was waiting for someone to review another of my entries xd .

Anyway,about the avatar,I wasn't trying to put a ton of gold on different parts of the body because I was trying to put emphasis on the pale blue and white I was using and the stars,seeing as how it was suppose to be a space themed outfit.The stockings I used to match with the blue hue of the yes I used,but then again I could have gone without them since a couple of other people mentioned they weren't necessary.The boots I used...well,I just wanted to use boots.We don't have a wide variety of white boots and I didn't want to use shoe or heels because it would have taken away from what I had in mind.Regardless of what some may feel,I consider this one of my better entries,and if I didn't like it I wouldn't have submitted it.Even so,I want to thank everyone that did and for those whose eyes I offended you'll live,because I have seen and done worst.


Also I don't know what the deal is with automatically pegging something that uses white wings as an angel.It wasn't meant to be nor even resemble one,because I think it would have been mentioned it in the description I made (which I think alot of people failed to read when they voted let alone review it D; ).Plus that outfit is the sister outfit to the Galaxy Bounce outfit I submitted twice to less success to that one.But what's done is done,and none of you can unsee it.I think my next entry will be an angel/elven/loli/sparkle clutter just to see how many peoples' heads I can make explode dramallama .



▬ ▬ ▬ ▬ ▬
[♥] [♦] [♥]
     
I officially don't give a damn about your wordgames title.Get over yourself.

No amount of therapy will ever make this right.
http://xrl.us/bf3pzbhttp://xrl.us/bf3qduhttp://xrl.us/bf3qn3
...What is your deal?
Thank the heavens, my dear. You're finally back to bring some form of sanity to the AA. You have not a clue as to how happy it makes me to see you back. http://gaiarch.gaiatools.com/emotes/greenhar.gif
 
     

http://tinyurl.com/yjuf35v

http://tinyurl.com/ykfwuzk
Seme to my uke.
Art from you = heart
@DeviantArt :: Natsuki Fangirl
 
Kunai Jones
Sky of the Silver Ocean
I was surprised to see the Dread Pirate Roberts cosplay. I adore that movie, so I would judge it very harshly myself, by it was oddly good...the hair seems a little off even though it can hardly be seen. I think that the Westley cosplay made this week almost worth it. <3

I did have a hard time with the hair, the head-shape made any protrusion from the back extra noticable, and Gaia doesn't really have a tiny ponytail option, so I stripped it down to bare bones. I'm glad you liked it otherwise, though. Thinking about taking a swing at Inigo next week on the other side of the duel. mrgreen


Hm, alright then. That really sucks, it would be perfect if Gaia had mini ponytails that could be bought and attached to hair. I didn't really know what hair option would ever fix it myself(I suck with avatars), but everything else really picked it up. Oh, that would be quite interesting to see. I think I remember one Inigo sometime, but I'm not sure. It would still be interesting to see, Princess Bride cosplays aren't very common.
     
||Ocean||
The place I belong

Jumping Jehosaphat - Thank you so much!
Thanks to the GCD Fairy too for the Kottan Bell!!!
Glad to see you are back. I always enjoyed your thread. Always amusing to see what others have to say about the avatars in the winners circle.

This week.. was pretty sad. :C What the hell is going on with avatars... seriously.
 
     

http://tinyurl.com/m9on2b
Call me Rin~
I am an '03 member.
I'm an exchanger/vendor. Find me in the Exchange. Lul.
Don't know what to quest for...
Visit my art shop via banner above.
http://heartlesspuppet.deviantart.com
< 1 2 ... 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 ... 54 55 56 > >>

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

We will be phasing out support for your browser soon.

Please upgrade to one of these more modern browsers.