Welcome to Gaia :: THINK before you comment or rate in the Art Arena

Log In

Forgot your login?

Sign Up

Register
 
GST

Do you think this thread should be stickied?

Yes 0.70886075949367 70.9% [ 56 ]
No 0.29113924050633 29.1% [ 23 ]
Total Votes: 79
Tags: thief  thieves  arena  comment  rate 
Export this topic to other sites using WildFire!
forum:6, topic:40230977
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
Lately, I have just started going back to the art arena. I decided to go through the top images, about HALF of them were taken from other artists, and the thieves were getting a LARGE amount of credit. The problem is that most people here don't know how to tell if a picture is stolen. So I decided to create a thread on how to tell.

A picture is probably stolen if...
1.) The picture is commonly seen on photobucket or other image hosting sites.
2.) The artist's comment is short and does not give information on how he/she drew it.
3.) The image is outstandingly great but the "artist" gives it a lame title or comment.
4.) The image is very detailed but also very small. Some images can only be copied from a small source. Keep an eye out for distortion or shrinking of images.
5.)Also, if you feel like checking out their gallery and other pictures they claim to have done, you can tell easily. If the pictures posted up have completely different styles to them, thats another hint.
6.) The "artist" constantly posts amaing pieces claiming to have done them in a small amount of time. ~*~ Sometimes artists do a thing called "speed painting". Which, is just like it sounds. Artists go to an oekaki or some other online drawing source and paint something quick. But there are ways to tell if the image is really a speed painting or the thief is just claiming to have drawn someone else's work in a matter of minutes.

Here are some examples of speed painting:
Link 1
Link 2
Link 3

See? These images arent perfect and don't have the prefect lines or coloring that would be required in a long run. After a while, its easy to tell them apart.


Q
: Is speed painting bad?

A:By all means, no. The artists don't use tracing or anything. I was only saying that it is better for people to learn if a picture is a speedpainting or not. That way, if the thief claims a certain amount of time that the picture took him, it would be easier to tell if they're lying.


If you see these hints, the image is most likely stolen. It doesn't mean they always are, but just keep an eye out for it. If you really want to make sure the image gets the right response, try searching for the image on photobucket or deviantart.

I know there are a lot of bots in the art arena, and I can't stop them from commenting, but if I can get some people to tell the difference between a stolen piece of work, and a real drawing that someone on gaia drew, that would be great =]


What to do:
If you aren't sure whether the picture is stolen or not, but theres a large chance it is, don't comment or rate on it. Its only fair.
If you are positive the image is stolen, report it to the mods. They'll probably remove it faster if you include a link to the actual artist's site or account.
Commenting on stolen art really doesn't help the situation, but it sure is fun to yell at those creeps. =]


If you're sick of thieves and want to make a difference in the art arena, post this banner link to this thread on your profile or guild: (also please rate up =] )



(It was broken up into two parts to avoid a page stretch. Copy both halves and paste them without a space in between.)

[url=http://www.gaiaonline.com/forum/art-discussion/think-before-you-comment-or-rate-in-the-art-arena/t.40230977/]
[img]http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y263/Origami_ash/artbann.png[/img][/url]


Please comment here to keep this thread alive. (personal experiences with thieves, other methods they use, other ways of telling is its a fake) People need to know about this.

In a related thread....
HOW TO CONSTRUCTIVELY CRITIQUE
Well, you've learned how to identify a thief, but, if the art really is the work of that person, don't you want to give them the credit they deserve? Learn to critique properly. =]

 
     
 
Yeah that pisses me off. Tracing something isnt art. Really.
I once commented on a picture I saw from an art book that teaches how to color and prepare anime artwork in several different ways. The "artist" was like "LOLOL I DREW IT ISNT IT GOOD?" No. It looked absolutely traced. You can tell a picture is traced if its lines look TOO clean but not smooth and straight. So I told them off and they continued to claim that they drew it until I posted the REAL picture.
     



Trust no man, fear no b***h. ♥


"Divided_Element"

5.) The "artist" constantly posts amaing pieces claiming to have done them in a small amount of time.


Sorry but there are artists are are amazing for doing works in a short amount of time because they are speed painting. Granted, there are jerks that do what you said, but it's a different story if the person's and the work is speed paint. :/
 
     


~*~

I'm a dirt poor artist who doesn't have a shop. So please don't ask for avi art. D:
 
"Espiritual"
"Divided_Element"

5.) The "artist" constantly posts amaing pieces claiming to have done them in a small amount of time.


Sorry but there are artists are are amazing for doing works in a short amount of time because they are speed painting. Granted, there are jerks that do what you said, but it's a different story if the person's and the work is speed paint. :/
Usually the artist will say it's speed paint. Because then they look hardcore. If someone says "LOL I DREW DIS IN 30MINUTES N STUFF" Then I'd be a little suspicious.
     



Trust no man, fear no b***h. ♥


"Black Cherry Milkshake"
"Espiritual"
"Divided_Element"

5.) The "artist" constantly posts amaing pieces claiming to have done them in a small amount of time.


Sorry but there are artists are are amazing for doing works in a short amount of time because they are speed painting. Granted, there are jerks that do what you said, but it's a different story if the person's and the work is speed paint. :/

Usually the artist will say it's speed paint. Because then they look hardcore. If someone says "LOL I DREW DIS IN 30MINUTES N STUFF" Then I'd be a little suspicious.

Well there are ways to see if it's a speed paint or not. If you look at the different characteristics that are found in between the two, you can tell whether or not it's a speed paint or if it was stolen.

IE of speed paintings:
http://www.linesandcolors.com/images/2006-06/verhasselt_450.jpg
http://mv.cgcommunity.com/images/videosketch.jpg
http://fuskbugg.se/pub/misc/SinCityklar.jpg

If you look at it, speed painting is not about refinement but getting an idea or statement down as fast as possible.
 
     


~*~

I'm a dirt poor artist who doesn't have a shop. So please don't ask for avi art. D:
 
"Black Cherry Milkshake"
"Espiritual"
"Divided_Element"

5.) The "artist" constantly posts amaing pieces claiming to have done them in a small amount of time.


Sorry but there are artists are are amazing for doing works in a short amount of time because they are speed painting. Granted, there are jerks that do what you said, but it's a different story if the person's and the work is speed paint. :/


Usually the artist will say it's speed paint. Because then they look hardcore. If someone says "LOL I DREW DIS IN 30MINUTES N STUFF" Then I'd be a little suspicious.

~*~

Well there are ways to see if it's a speed paint or not. If you look at the different characteristics that are found in between the two, you can tell whether or not it's a speed paint or if it was stolen.

IE of speed paintings:
http://www.linesandcolors.com/images/2006-06/verhasselt_450.jpg
http://mv.cgcommunity.com/images/videosketch.jpg
http://fuskbugg.se/pub/misc/SinCityklar.jpg

If you look at it, speed painting is not about refinement but getting an idea or statement down as fast as possible.
     


~*~

I'm a dirt poor artist who doesn't have a shop. So please don't ask for avi art. D:
Yeah, you're right about the speed painting. and you can tell whether its done in there or not. But if a picture looks perfect and it would be impossible to do in speed paint, thats a sure tip-off. I'll try adding this into the first post with those links you posted.
 
     
 
Another way to tell if art is stolen is if the "artist" goes off rambling about how it was done in Photoshop, and it was obviously done with traditional materials, or the opposite: they claim it was done traditionally, but it is clearly digital art. I've read some "artist comments" where the person rambled on and on about how they'd done something with Photoshop, and they obviously knew NOTHING about the program. rolleyes
     
Another red flag I notice a lot is when an artist claims it took them "weeks" or "months" for a single drawing; usually it's a nicely detailed drawing, but not anything that would have taken that long. The thief just doesn't have a realistic idea of how long it takes to do a drawing (same thing as when they claim a drawing took less time than it clearly did).

And it's best to find proof before you report; it's usually not very hard to do a couple of searches--do separate ones on Google Image Search, Photobucket and DeviantART, and you're almost certain to find it.
 
     
     
 
I don't even bother in the Art Arena because of this.
heart
     
Good points, you guys 3nodding
 
     
 
I hate when I see this in the Art Arena... It's Just Not Right. =/
     
~*Donations*~

*Sanctus Sacrificum
*Care Bear Assassin
*xZ3Ox
I wish this could be stickied ;_;
 
     
 
"forbiddenshadow"
I wish this could be stickied ;_;
Yeah, more people need to see this ;_;
     
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >