Welcome to Gaia! ::

What do you think of dubbing (in GENERAL)

I LOVE IT 0.140625 14.1% [ 27 ]
Sometimes it's good, sometimes it's bad, sometimes it's ok 0.625 62.5% [ 120 ]
I don't care one way or another as long as I get my anime 0.10416666666667 10.4% [ 20 ]
OMFG KILL THE DUBBERS I HATE DUBS!!!!!! 0.078125 7.8% [ 15 ]
Poll/Gold Ho 0.052083333333333 5.2% [ 10 ]
Total Votes:[ 192 ]
< 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
User Image
My story is one witnessed only by the moon
______________________________________________________________________________



Ah, it seems I find someone I can finally agree with.
iTsunayoshi Sawada's avatar
  • 100
  • 100
  • 150
User Image - Blocked by "Display Image" Settings. Click to show.
[x]Gaia's Official Tsunayoshi Sawada/Giotto, as well as Gaia's official Tsuna/Giotto RPer.[x]

User Image User Image User Image

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
#1 Tsunayoshi Sawada/Giotto/Hayato Gokudera fanwhore of everywhere and anywhere.
I have people who will back me up on this claim, so don't even think about trying to take it from me.
Yes, I take my obsession to frightening extremes Got a problem with it? Too bad.

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++


Agreed. Not all of them are bad. Some dubs are better than the Japanese versions.
Besides, people who rave about subtitles forget that the subs are done by a group of people, and they contain way too many flaws. Subs are a horrible way to watch anime. I only trust subs when I buy my DVDs.




+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Proud Starter and Leader of Gaia's
Anti-Yamamoto and Anti-8059 team. I hate him, and I'm not afraid to admit it.
User Image
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

I also despise 8027 with a burning passion. Don't torture Tsuna by
putting him with that ******** idiot.
The only anime dubs I accept are Cowboy bebop and Trigun
I tend to like fansubs because I don't want to wait months/years for a show to get to the US and dubbed. XD As for dubs, I think Kyo's English VA (Fruits Basket) did a decent job dubbing....but on the other hand, I like Envy's (FMA) Japanese VA better than the English one. ._.
Like, for realz dog. No doubt, this is played out. I can't step into a brothel without renting out a hostel. Them characters is real slim shady, going out style just like did wayne bradey.

Oh Snap!

I felt this was all I could contribute to your arguement. Being a dub doesn't make things worse. If you've seen YuGiOh the Abridged Series, you'd understand. But if you were a fan of One piece, and you heard the attrocious rap, then you'd lose all sense of rational thought as well. By the way, if you've read this far, you'll notice the terrible rap I made was an ironic homage to the One piece rap.

When you're body is wet it hardens so that I can clobber you!

Censorship is a good topic to bring up here, but I really think a series like one piece can't transfer it's awesomeness when watered down.
Heh, I dislike the ratings (PG-13, R, etc.) in the U.S. I find it strange how shonen-ai is rated higher than het with similar content. It really irks me if they try to censor out hints/fanservice of BL or make it more vague.
Tenko72's avatar
  • 150
  • 150
  • 100
Creativerealms
Most dubs are good. It's just when a dub is bad it's Really REALLy bad. And people tend to focus on the bad dubs. A 4kids dub is not a common dub people it's actually the oppisite of the average dub.

If there was no such thing as dubbing anime, then all anime would be like one of those old silant movies, no talking at all.
User ImageShocking...

QFT. And emphasis is mine. People seem to be forgetting what the definition of "dub" is.

...isn't it?User Image


animesoul167
The funniest dubs I ever heard were in the video game Shenmue. (I don't think I spelled that right) It was on the Dreamcast, then moved to the Xbox. Sorry, I'm not that familiar with bad anime dubs. Most people say 4Kids' One Piece, but I think those were mostly editing and censoring issues right?
User ImageShocking...

Shenmue had decent acting, but the scripts were hilarious! "Do you know where there are any Chinese people?" rofl

...isn't it?User Image
One piece. Dubbing you can count on.
When I say 4kids dubs are bad I mean the voices as much as the edits. David Moo's Sanji for the lose.
Seraphim_Dyre
Inari Shiji
i... hate... dubs... because... the... characters... need... to... talk... this... slow... so... the... scenes... are... the... same... length...


Uh can you please cite at least ONE (1) example please?
umm.... everything. they dont talk like people usually would, they talk like 2 times slower so that the scenes end up being the same length. cause japanese takes longer to say a sentence than in english it makes since that the english people need to speak slower.
Inari Shiji
Seraphim_Dyre
Inari Shiji
i... hate... dubs... because... the... characters... need... to... talk... this... slow... so... the... scenes... are... the... same... length...


Uh can you please cite at least ONE (1) example please?
umm.... everything. they dont talk like people usually would, they talk like 2 times slower.


The only animated show I have ever seen where people talk like that was Thundercats and thats an American cartoon.
Creativerealms
Inari Shiji
Seraphim_Dyre
Inari Shiji
i... hate... dubs... because... the... characters... need... to... talk... this... slow... so... the... scenes... are... the... same... length...


Uh can you please cite at least ONE (1) example please?
umm.... everything. they dont talk like people usually would, they talk like 2 times slower.


The only animated show I have ever seen where people talk like that was Thundercats and thats an American cartoon.
well everything ive watched is like that. like naruto and bleach. where the scene is just a fixed point and the people are talking its soooooo long. but thats what i think.
People that say subtitles are the best way to go... they must like to strain their eyes, but I have also seen some pretty good subbing. Dubbing on the other hand... sometimes the dubbing process is changed, because there are phrases in Japanese that wouldn't make any sense at all in English, or other languages. Also, subbing is also out there for people who want to get the jump on a show, or an episode that just came out about a week ago in Japan, or another country.

So... look at it this way. Neither is good or bad, but they are both ok. My opinion.
Inari Shiji
Creativerealms
Inari Shiji
Seraphim_Dyre
Inari Shiji
i... hate... dubs... because... the... characters... need... to... talk... this... slow... so... the... scenes... are... the... same... length...


Uh can you please cite at least ONE (1) example please?
umm.... everything. they dont talk like people usually would, they talk like 2 times slower.


The only animated show I have ever seen where people talk like that was Thundercats and thats an American cartoon.
well everything ive watched is like that. like naruto and bleach. where the scene is just a fixed point and the people are talking its soooooo long. but thats what i think.


I have yet to hear a single scene like that in the Naruto dub. I find that dub to be very well done and well acted. I have actually found the emotional parts to be superior in the English dub of Naruto.

I will take your word on Bleach as I refuse to watch that show, in any form.
Inari Shiji
Creativerealms
Inari Shiji
Seraphim_Dyre
Inari Shiji
i... hate... dubs... because... the... characters... need... to... talk... this... slow... so... the... scenes... are... the... same... length...


Uh can you please cite at least ONE (1) example please?
umm.... everything. they dont talk like people usually would, they talk like 2 times slower.


The only animated show I have ever seen where people talk like that was Thundercats and thats an American cartoon.
well everything ive watched is like that. like naruto and bleach. where the scene is just a fixed point and the people are talking its soooooo long. but thats what i think.


Did you watch the subbed version in comparison to the dubbed?

Quick Reply

Submit
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get Items
Get Gaia Cash
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff