full metal alchemist new vs old

[liexlife]

okay so whats your thoughts on the new full metal alchemist brotherhood vs the old full metal alchemist?

[II Yami Bakura II]

No vs threads.
I personally didn't like the first series ending, and I liked the manga more than the first series, so I like Brotherhood more.

[oh alk]

The manga > Brotherhood > first anime.
But I love all three versions. <3

[Hoshiko Yakimura]

I haven't seen the new one (I'm waiting on the English dub), therefore I can have no opinion.

[iDexion]

although the OVA lacks a smallish wrath. I still like the new one more.

[Hiroy]

Brotherhood. It makes more sense.

[Commander Viral]

http://tinyurl.com/y8kl833
------------- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

I love both anime and the manga equally.

[CreativeButLazy]

The original manga is vastly superior to both, but I like Brotherhood a lot more than the first anime.

[Selmareve]

___________________________________________

Brotherhood wins by default because it has Ling.
Though the manga is superior to both anime.

[Jack_of_London]

I keep on hearing the police have caught me but they wont fix me just yet.

I like the manga more.

I have laughed when they look so clever and talk about being on the right track.

[Buroukun Enjeru]

"Everyone sees the light eventually.
_Destiny has lead you to me."
"An epiphany, you burn so pretty;
_Shrouded in celestial light,
_You shine the most bright.
_You are a shining light."

♥
Current/"Old" confuses me beyond all reason, frankly.
Brotherhood makes much more sense.

[Yoru-chan nya nya]

I like the first anime the best. Brotherhood's art is ugly. Same with the manga. I'd enjoy both infinitely more if the art was less ... fat.

[i S i l v e r m y s t]

________

No VS threads!
Manga! > Brotherhood

[silverwingedwitch]

Both where good, but I'm loving Brotherhood more right now
It makes more sense ^^