Welcome to Gaia! :: full metal alchemist new vs old | Forum

Register FaceBook Login Login

 

 
GST

Welcome to Gaia's forums, where millions of members gather to discuss random stuff, make new friends,
complain about life, argue about nothing, laugh at dumb pictures, discuss serious issues and/or curse like sailors.

Lurking is creepy. Quit skulking in the shadows and join the conversation!

Register to reply

Advertisement
Tags: full  metal  alchemist 
Share:  
forum:3, topic:54677177
1 2 3 >
okay so whats your thoughts on the new full metal alchemist brotherhood vs the old full metal alchemist?
 
     
 
     
 
 
 
 



I think Brotherhood is vastly superior in every way possible.

inb4Ciyana
 
 
 
     
 
http://i37.tinypic.com/24maja0.png
#1 SKU, Juri Arisugawa, and Howard Link fan of the AMC
#2 Slayers fan of the AMC
Ciyana Fanwhore


Amazing art by Fuhrer Grell. <3
Tap my tank? If you grab, comments are love. <3
No vs threads.
I personally didn't like the first series ending, and I liked the manga more than the first series, so I like Brotherhood more.
 
     

My birthday is December the 19th.
Most disliked series for me = Haruhi.
LPL's my naughty little girl.
#1 Pairing threads reporter of the amc. # of pairing threads destroyed: 400
 

        The manga > Brotherhood > first anime.
        But I love all three versions. <3
     


I haven't seen the new one (I'm waiting on the English dub), therefore I can have no opinion.
 
     

Chibi Santa Seto is kawaii desu desu, no?
My titles
Abarai Renji is meh hubby/honeh
I am so obsessed with LOTR, I should probably go into therapy
 
although the OVA lacks a smallish wrath. I still like the new one more.
     


Brotherhood. It makes more sense.
 
     
Jesus Christ!! It's cold!!
 
http://tinyurl.com/y8kl833
------------- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

            I love both anime and the manga equally.
     

A/M/C's resident Johnny Depp, Tim Burton, and Disney enthusiast.

HNNNNNNNNNG Public Enemies on DVD November 10~!!
The original manga is vastly superior to both, but I like Brotherhood a lot more than the first anime.
 
     
http://tiny.cc/u00b0
If I glow, bump here please!
 

___________________________________________

Brotherhood wins by default because it has Ling.
Though the manga is superior to both anime.
     
So freaking excited for Durarara.

You have no idea.
I keep on hearing the police have caught me but they wont fix me just yet.




I like the manga more.


I have laughed when they look so clever and talk about being on the right track.
 
     
We Wish You a Bloody Christmas...

http://www.annual-pass.com/news_events/blog/uploads/dungeons_santa.jpg

...And a Deadly New Year



#1 Jack the Ripper Fan of the A/M/C
 

"Everyone sees the light eventually.
_Destiny has lead you to me."

"An epiphany, you burn so pretty;
_Shrouded in celestial light,
_You shine the most bright.
_You are a shining light."




Current/"Old" confuses me beyond all reason, frankly.
Brotherhood makes much more sense.
     

Riddle me this, riddle me that:
Who's afraid of a Big Black Bat?

I have three art requests.
I CAN WALK AGAIN 8D
The idea of my avatar is that I got flowers from Sartorius.
Flowers in winter. It's romantic.




I like the first anime the best. Brotherhood's art is ugly. Same with the manga. I'd enjoy both infinitely more if the art was less ... fat.


 
     
#1 supporter of Kanon X Maria. This claim cannot be disputed.


Also #1 Shuhei Hisagi fangirl and #2 Envy fangirl.
 

________

No VS threads!
Manga! > Brotherhood
     


Yo GinHiji fans look here!

A/M/C'S
#1 Alk fangirl!! (<3)
#0 Gintoki Sakata fangirl!
#1 Hiromu Arakawa fanfag!

Questing for Divided Stars
28k/423k




Former Daydream_Alchemist
Both where good, but I'm loving Brotherhood more right now
It makes more sense ^^
 
     
http://r.undev.org/?r=100445
Oro? heart
#1 Kenshin Himura Fan of the A/M/C heart
Like Fireflies by Owl City? Like watching AMV's? Like Rurouni Kenshin?
Then check out my new amv in my Pro!
OR Click Here! ;D and comment!
1 2 3 >

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

We will be phasing out support for your browser soon.

Please upgrade to one of these more modern browsers.