Personally, I don't like Steins Gate so much. There is so much talking and not much action going on. I think I can follow along with the plot, but it just seems too absurd for me to keep my interest. IMO, there are arguably many other great animes this season that are better than Steins Gate such as C, Ao no Exorcist, Hanasaku Iroha, and Deadman Wonderland.
Steins;Gate game bored me, but it was pretty decent.
And Puella Magi Madoka Magica IS 2011. There were delays with airing the episodes, more specifically the final two episodes, in order to improve the animation quality which still ended in 'Meguca-quality' frames.