Tenko72
Despite it's title, Puella Magi Madoka Magica is like Code Geass. The way the powers work and its tone are similar. There's a manipulative main character who's kind of like Lelouche too. I don't want to say much and spoil you.
If you do end up liking that one, then I'll recommend Bokurano too. It's tone is similar. It's like NGE, only more pessimistic.
Odiah recommended some good ones too. If you liked FMA, then I think you'll like those too.
My sister in law recommended Puella Magi Madoka Magica, but you're right I did blow off because of the title....
With a second recommendation I'll give it a try! We're finishing FMA Brotherhood this evening. but I just hate not havering a good Anime to watch
xp
Thank you for you input!