Welcome to Gaia! :: Site Feedback - Rules and Guidelines

Log In

Forgot your login?

Sign Up

Register
 
GST
Export this topic to other sites using WildFire!
forum:137, topic:6643059
Post: 6643059_1 created on Thu Mar 17, 2005 11:32 pmPosted: Thu Mar 17, 2005 11:32 pm
Site Feedback: Rules and Guidelines


Welcome to Site Feedback! This is a place to suggest enhancements, features, and ideas to help make the user experience in Gaia better. All ideas and opinions about Gaia are welcome here. We do, however, encourage you to express your ideas and opinions in a civil manner. If you just want to gather support for an idea, use the new Petitions Subforum.

Decided Issues
This thread contains some suggestions and ideas that come up frequently and are either already being planned, or are impractical for Gaia. Please take a look here before you post. If you post a topic that deals with one of these subjects, your thread will probably be recycled.
    In this thread:
  • 1st Post: Intro
  • 2nd Post: Forum Etiquette
  • 3rd Post: How to Suggest
  • 4th Post: What Does not Belong
  • 5th Post: Subforum: Petitions
  • 6th Post: Additional Abuse/Flaming Note
  • 7th Post: Personal Attacks
 
     
Post: 6643059_2 created on Thu Mar 17, 2005 11:52 pmPosted: Thu Mar 17, 2005 11:52 pm
 
Forum Etiquette


Here is a list of the basic rules and etiquitte which we expect all (newbies, oldbies, and regulars alike), of our users to abide by. Please keep these in mind when posting.

REMEMBER: You still have to follow all general rules of Gaia that are stipulated by the Terms of Service, Rules & Guidelines, etc.


  • Excessive bumping is unneccessary. Site Feedback is a slower moving forum than some others and topics usually stay on the first page for quite a while. We encourage you to not bump if your topic is still on the first page.

    Bumping a excessive number of threads to the front page of Site Feedback will be considered spamming. This includes your own threads or other people's threads.

  • No idea is without some merit. Responding to somene's idea with, "That's stupid, get lost!" generally only starts an argument. Explain your point of view, and explain it civilly. Remember that flaming and trolling are violations of the Terms of Service and stating your opinion does not give you an excuse to do so without facing the consequences. If someone is out of line, report the thread or post and leave it to a moderator.

  • No criticism is without some merit. Just because someone does not agree with you doesn't mean you have the right to flame them. Listen to what they have to say. If you don't like it, fine. You don't have to. However, you must abide by the terms of service. Remember that flaming and trolling are violations of the Terms of Service and someone disagreeing with your idea does not give you an excuse to do so without facing the consequences. If someone is out of line, report the thread or post and leave it to a moderator.

  • Site Feedback is for discussion. When you post an idea in Site Feedback, be aware that you are opening the idea to constructive discussion about the pros and cons of the suggestion as well as how the idea could be improved. If you take actions to block some or all discussion or refuse certain input, your thread can be locked or moved. For example, it would not be acceptable to include in your post something like this: "If you don't like my idea, then you are not allowed to reply." In accordance to the two prior rules, discussion should remain constructive and civil.

  • Check the first page before you post! New ideas are wonderful and they are most welcome here. However, please make certain that you're not repeating a suggestion that is already clearly in current discussion.

  • If it's misplaced or needs to be recycled, please report it to a Moderator or forum Helper, then leave. Please read the What Does not Belong section a couple posts down for information about which threads should go in other forums. People do make threads in the wrong forum. Please be polite about it. If you must, explain politely. If someone else has already done that, then please refrain from posting. Otherwise, simply make a report and it will get moved.
     
Post: 6643059_3 created on Fri Mar 18, 2005 12:03 amPosted: Fri Mar 18, 2005 12:03 am
How to Suggest

  • Try to make accurate titles for your suggestions and ideas. That is, title the thread with your suggestion instead making titles like "good suggestion here", "i have a suggestion". This will probably help attract users with same/similar ideas for discussion.

  • Try not to make repeat threads. Many threads on the same topic in no way make it a better suggestion. Please make an effort to scan at least the first page of the forum for the same/similar topic. (This is a suggestion not a rule or guideline.)

At the moment we also have three official suggestion threads. These are good places to put your ideas where they will be seen eventually by the site administrators as well as other users. These are:

  • Official Item Suggestion Thread: Have a new idea which you think no one has thought up before on something which we need to have on Gaia? This is the place to post it. However, first make sure you check the:

      Official Item Suggestion Digest: (Check this before posting in the IST). This lists all the ideas that have been suggested on Gaia already and which the admins are aware of. If it's listed here, it's already been suggested and the admins know about it. You are free to still suggest it again, but it won't be a new idea.

  • Battle Suggestion Thread: Have an idea for a cool new piece of armor, or battle feature? This is where to post it. This is a list of all the different battle ideas your fellow Gaians have come up with for when the battle system finally starts up. It is also a place where ideas are discussed in detail. If you want to try and figure out exactly how realistic it is to have an item or a specific way of running battles, post here as well. The one thing to keep in mind is that a enormous number of weapons have already been suggested. For the moment, until the battle system has been released, please don't post additional weapon suggestions.

  • Feature Suggestion Thread: Have an idea for a feature which you feel would make the site better? You guessed it, this is a good place to post if you want the admins to hear about your idea. For new forums, new worlds or special little goodies that you feel Gaia just has to have, there is no better place. Before you post there though...

    Please read The first page. There is a list, arranged according to feature type of all the different ideas that users have already suggested here. In addition, there is a list of things which are currently on the way. Check it out!


Note: The existence of these threads does not mean that you cannot create threads to discuss item, feature, or battle suggestions with other members. However, if you post your suggestion in one of the stickies, it is more likely to be seen and noticed by those that actually have the ability to add new items or features, and who are responsible for designing the battle system. If you want to discuss your thoughts with other users, you can still make a new topic about it. If it is in the Decided Issues thread though, it will probably be recycled. One word or one sentence suggestions, we encourage you to simply post in these stickies.
 
     
Post: 6643059_4 created on Fri Mar 18, 2005 12:08 amPosted: Fri Mar 18, 2005 12:08 am
 
What Does Not Belong


DI's: The Decided Issues thread contains some suggestions and ideas that come up frequently and are either already being planned, or are impractical for Gaia. Please take a look here before you post. If you post a topic that deals with one of these subjects, your thread will probably be recycled.

"I need Help!/How do I?" If you have questions about the site, or need help with something, please use: Questions and Assistance. This forum is dedicated to the giving answers to users unfamiliar with the site, reporting site errors, and finding ways to help with them.

Technical problems and difficulties: For reporting bugs or discovering if workarounds to them have been found, check out Bug Reports & Technical Support. If you think you've found a layering issue or glitch with equipping items onto your avatar, try Avatar System 2.0 Q&F.

NPC and Character developments, Comments about 'the users' in a particular forum, etc.: For this type of discussion, the Gaia Community Discussion forum is where you want to go. This forum is dedicated to discussing the Gaia world, NPCs, storylines, avatars, and the community.

Petitions: Petitions belong in the Petitions subforum. Please don't create petitions in the main Site Feedback forum.

FAQ's and Tutorials about Gaia: These belong in the Gaia Guides and Resources subforum.
     
Post: 6643059_5 created on Fri Mar 18, 2005 3:56 amPosted: Fri Mar 18, 2005 3:56 am
Subforums


Petitions was created to give Gaians a place to gather support for their ideas and suggestions from other Gaians. These ideas and suggestions must be about Gaia. Petitions for non-Gaia related issues can be made in the Chatterbox

Please read the Rules for the Petitions Forum before posting in there.

We also recommend that you search through the forum for another petition that might already exist for your item or feature idea. May as well keep all the support for a particular thing in one place, eh?
 
     
I love you grandpa.
Post: 6643059_6 created on Mon Sep 19, 2005 12:52 amPosted: Mon Sep 19, 2005 12:52 am
 
Reporting Problems and Contacting Moderators


Sometimes problems come up that require moderator involvement. They can be simple, like a misplaced thread, or a bit more involved, like a user abusing or harassing another user.


Report this Post

Use this button to report a specific post that is in violation of the ToS. Clicking it will take you to the report form which you then fill out and submit. Since this button is located right next to the QUOTE button, you must be careful not to confuse the two. Abuse of the report button will lead to your account getting a temporary ban. Do not use this button to report misplaced or inappropriate threads (ie. use the Thread Report talked about next).

Report this Thread
Located at the bottom of the page, you can find it right next to the Subscribe button. Please use this button to report threads that are inappropriate or misplaced. Again, abuse of the report system can lead to a ban of your account.

Report a Hacking
You can find this link at the bottom of the main forums page. Use this form if you or someone you know has been hacked. Please provide all information you have that will help the investigation along. This includes usernames, emails, links and screencaps. Please be patient when submitting a hacking report. It can take anywhere from a few days to weeks or more for a mod to begin work on your case.

Report a Scam
You can find this link at the bottom of the main forums page. Use this form if a user has scammed you or is attempting to scam others. Please provide all information you have available including usernames, links and screencaps. Please be patient when submitting a scamming report. It can take anywhere from a few days to weeks or more for a mod to begin work on your case.

Report Abuse/Harassment
You can find this link at the bottom of the main forums page. Use this form if a user is abusing or harrassing you outside of the forums, such as through PMs. If the abuse is occuring in a thread, please use the "Report this Post" button. Please provide all information you have available including usernames, links and screencaps of PMs. Please be patient when submitting a harrassment report. It can take anywhere from a few days to weeks or more for a mod to begin work on your case.

Feedback Form
There are some issues that are not suitable for the reporting system. The feedback form is there for you when you need to report something to the admins. Inquiries about monthly collectables, reporting an inventory glitch, contesting a ban or any other matter that a moderator would be unable to assist in are all valid reasons for filling out the feedback form. Please be patient when using the feedback form. As you can imagine, the admins receive MANY of these a day and as such it can take some time before they get back to you.

If you are uncertain, PM an online Moderator (Site Moderator preferably) first and they will be able to help you with where to go.



When and How to Contact a Mod Directly!

Ideally, users should use the reporting system to report violations. But sometimes there are situations where immediate mod intervention is needed. Such instances usually involve when a user is continuously breaking some kind of rule. In these cases it's perfectly acceptable to PM an online mod to deal with the matter. Examples of these cases are:

  • People continuously posting offensive images
  • People continuously posting PG-13 violating images
  • People continuously spamming off-site advertisement
  • Serial trolls
  • Any sort of bot account
  • People continuously scam spamming
  • Anyone continuously violating major rules

If you see any of these, then find an online moderator. You can do this by clicking the "View forum moderators" link at the top of the forum. If you do not see any online moderators assigned to that forum, you can switch to a different forum and view that forums moderators to find online moderators.
     
I love you grandpa.
Post: 6643059_7 created on Tue May 30, 2006 5:56 pmPosted: Tue May 30, 2006 5:56 pm
Abuse/Flaming Posts


Site Feedback is a forum for all Gaians to post their suggestions and ideas for the site. This forum should be an open place with a friendly atmosphere. The admins value all user feedback - this includes feedback from newbies and people who do not frequent Site Feedback.

Posters do not deserve to be abused for posting duplicate suggestions, for posting with less than perfect grammar, having "bad" ideas, etc. It is inappropriate to respond to suggestions and feedback threads with name calling, threats, spam and other inappropriate posts.

If you cannot respond in a respectful manner, then please refrain from posting. Failure to do so can lead to an official warning.

Here are some examples of posts that are not appropriate for Site Feedback and that you may get an official warning for:

Quote:
Haha. You're funny. We both know that this is going to be a feature. Stop wasting time with stupid questions like this.
Quote:
This forum is not for whining. If you want to start a petition like ties for women, go to the petition forum.

God you n00bs whine WAAAAAAYYYYY too much...
Quote:
GAIA IS NOT GETTING TATTOOS. GET OVER IT. STOP MAKING THREADS.
Quote:
It said suggestions...Not bull s**t.
Quote:
Shut up and stop bitching. You hate how people act? Then Leave and never come back. Good-Bye.
 
     
Post: 6643059_8 created on Sat Apr 28, 2007 1:16 amPosted: Sat Apr 28, 2007 1:16 am
 
Personal Attacks


In the past few weeks, we have noticed a trend where an individual moderator or staff member for the Gaia team is called out by name and ridiculed in public. Due to concerns, we have decided to alter the rules as follows:

From this point forward, users are asked not to make threads criticizing any moderator, admin, or developer specifically. This does not mean that negative feedback about general features or the moderation system is no longer welcome, only that complaints of abuse and the like directed towards a specific member of the team will not be allowed.

Thus, a thread specifically attacking a single moderator, for example myself, will be considered illegal. However, any thread calling for reforms on the mod team or calling into question mod actions as a whole but not singling out any specific moderator will be considered appropriate.

Likewise, a thread criticizing a specific developer, asking for their firing or anything similar will be considered illegal. Comments on the events in general or the developer team as a group will be considered legal.

Any further attempts to single out a specific moderator, admin or developer will be treated as harassment and formal warnings will be issued. This rule will not be applied retro-actively.

Any issues with a moderator should be pm'ed directly to one of the following admins: Dri or Siskataya.

In addition, any issues with a developer individually, if abuse occurs should be sent to the same people.

Thank you for your time and attention.